BISHOP FRANCISCO CLAVER, S.J., D.D.

The images that Bishop Francisco Claver remembers from when he was growing up in Bontoc, Mountain Province, connect the land, the population growth through the years, and where the landscape changed from the shift s in land use and the movement of people. Quoting from an earlier paper1 of his, the crucial part that “culture plays in any scheme of social change” is also envisaged as he related aspects of the Cordillera. Bontoc, his cultural origins, and how the other cultures of the region increasingly live and struggle with the present state of the lands, the water, and the forests in a global world.

“The entire Mountain Province and the whole land (Cordillera) had a population of around 300,000-400,000. Now over a million people live in the Cordillera. In 1904, the population census in Bontoc registered about 4,000; now the population is 10,000. The population of the entire country was 6 million then, now it’s 80 million. If Bontoc followed the national rate of growth, there should be around 60,000 people, but Bontoc can’t support such a population. The carrying capacity is really only 4,000. Baguio City, pre-war, had a population of 20,000, and it’s now 400,000.

“Traveling between Bontoc and Baguio, there were no towns then between Sabangan (the town aft er Bontoc) and La Trinidad (the town before Baguio), a distance of over 140 kilometers. There were just forests, big pine forests. All the towns that are there now are all new, and that means these areas were forests before. The roads were exuding moisture, with many brooklets along the way as you travelled. Approaching Baguio from the lowlands, what struck the traveler then was the smell of pine trees. The traveler now will be welcomed by the smell of gas fumes.”

Further describing the landscape, Bishop Claver shares that “the vegetable farms that you see now as you travel the stretch of Benguet were started in the 1950s and the farmers came from Western Bontoc, not from Benguet. The original people had to move out, as the place cannot support them. But what was good for farming was bad for the rivers as these decreased in time. The water levels of the Agno and Chico Rivers drastically went down between 1995 and 2005. How do you restore all these water sources? I don’t know.

“Yes, from a distance, I can still see there are still forests, but the valleys are all cleared and converted, full of vegetable farms. When I was still with the Apostolic Vicariate of Bontoc-Lagawe, we wanted to plant trees. But then came the ancestral land concept through the IPRA (Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act) that defined the ancestral land in the concept of private property. In this I cannot see now where the real sense of preserving the forest is. One of the problems with reforestation is that it now encourages the privatization of ancestral lands. Those who grew up with a sense of private property are transferring this concept to ancestral land as the IPRA is implemented. For example, after IPRA, people started to subdivide the riverbanks, and many people who know how to use the law are now staking their claims as the owners. Before, it was easy to get stones from the river to use for tuping (stonewalling) as there was a sense of the taian (common resource). Now you have to ask permission or pay up. If you are from Bontoc, they would be ashamed to charge; if you are a foreigner (not from Bontoc), the attitude of charging for the stones evokes no cultural hesitation.”

Bishop Claver, however, believes that IPRA contributed to stopping the mining, in the sense that the government generally assumes people’s ready acceptance and acquiescence. “But in Benguet, where most of the mining went on and is still going on, people were weak. In the Mountain Province there is gold, but there is no mining. I remember an event that I always shared with people. In the 1930s, there were prospectors doing the surveying, and people were mad and wanted to attack them. The women said ‘No, don’t do that, we’ll handle this our way.’ One day, the women came down from the ridge above the campsite where the prospectors were, yelling and screaming while taking off all their clothes. All the campers fled never to return.”

The observation is that when the Cordillera says “no,” the government listens. Bishop Claver explains that “this is so because people in government who are from the Cordillera understand and know the power of the people and the protests. The Chico River Dam protests sprung from this land. But as this government becomes weaned from the culture, it becomes manipulative. Native people still have that sense of community and right.”

He views the efforts in “saving” the payeo (rice terraces) as futile, when these are all done for tourism purposes. Keep the people poor and you will keep the terraces; they are too much hard work and people would rather leave. “The educated Igorots have no more concern in terms of what’s happening in the ricefields, because they know it’s the end. Educated people, like me, are the ones interested in doing tourism. It is the educated who have gone out and seen the potential of mining that invest in it. Then, once people develop skin diseases in the rivers below, the response is to sue people in the upper areas where the mining is taking place.”

He also points out the impact of class distinctions in the relationship with the land. “In Ifugao, there are more tenants in the field than in Bontoc. There is a class of tenants and this class distinction is stronger in Ifugao than in Bontoc. In Bontoc, people have their own fields. In Ifugao, they are more class-conscious.”

Patterns of settlements within a community and the type of leadership contribute to how changes in the social landscape can occur. “In Kalinga, the notion of a pangat (headman) continues to prevail. In Ifugao, the pattern of settlements is family clan clusters set apart so it is the headman or head family that is of importance. In the Mountain Province, houses are clustered more as a villagewith less distinction of class and the ato (elders) or dap-ay (group of elders) traditionally lead. It is observed that it is easier to form BECs (Basic Ecclesial Communities) in the Mountain Province, while the charismatic movement can take an easier hold in Ifugao. But definitely, the Ifugaos are more artistic,” the Bishop from Bontoc concedes.

With the revival of autonomy discussions for the Cordillera region as a development vehicle, his view is that “if the Cordillera is autonomous, IPRA can be better implemented. But I am not supportive of this move, as I would prefer federations and keeping the Cordillera as one. The LGUs are wary of Cordillera governance, because of loss of contact with the people on the ground. This is so because the context of the ‘autonomy’ being discussed is that of the national government, which is just a huge milking cow. Federations will also allow senators to come from the regions, not just from Manila.”

Bishop Claver values the establishment of Schools of Living Traditions (SLT)2 in Mountain Province schools, because even if the students graduate as professionals, their sense of roots and of the environment are retained.

Asked as to whether the bishops are active in the environment, he clarified that “it’s not the bishops, it’s the social action centers (SACs) that define the environment agenda in the respective dioceses, because bishops will always do what the SACs tell them to do.”

For today’s youth, “I want to bring in the idea of culture while getting along in a globalized world. The more you are globalized, the more you have to be aware of your identity. You can have and share a common culture, but you have to have your own identity.”

Towards the end of our conversation, Bishop Claver asks questions. “When I hear people saying no to mining, that’s impossible, as we’ve been mining since the Stone Age. In the vicariate, we’ve always been against the quarrying for a long time. But when roads were to be built, sand was needed that will be taken from the rivers. So this was our question, ‘Can you still get the sand to build new roads?’ Can you do mining, without too much damage? If the vegetable gardens stop, the forests can possibly come back, but is that the approach?”

The bishop then brought us to the fishpond he built behind the seminary and he has been building stone paths, walls and banks out of the local adobe. He diverts the water from a creek that originates from three ponds and storm water of the university campus. During the dry season, he uses all the water. Running it over the stones and creating a flow improves the quality of the water and allows for lush bank vegetation and a regenerated environment.

Bishop Claver retired as the Apostolic Vicar of the Apostolic Vicariate of Bontoc-Lagawe in 2004. He holds an STB and STL from Woodstock College and a PhD degree in Anthropology from the University of Colorado. He served as chairman of the Episcopal Commission for Indigenous Peoples and of the Commission for Justice and Peace of the Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines.

1 Pope John Paul II and the Church of Asia by Francisco F. Claver, S.J. from http://eapi.admu.edu.ph/eapr005/f-claver.htm

2 A School of Living Tradition is one where a living master/culture bearer or culture specialist teaches skills and techniques of doing a traditional art or craft. The mode of teaching is non-formal, oral, and with practical demonstrations. The site may be thehouse of the living master, a community social hall, or a special center constructed.The group of learners is limited to the young people from the same ethno-linguisticcommunity. The SLTs is a program under the National Commission for Cultureand the Arts (NCCA) and is a response to UNESCO’s call for cultural heritage preservation through a living form that can be transmitted to the next generations.

(Source: NCCA website)

Download document in PDF format.

Aware of our identity in a global world

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *