ESSC shares the reflection and synthesis by Pedro Walpole SJ, ESSC Director for Research and Ecojesuit Global Coordinator, of the speakers’ presentations during the webinar Building a Benchmark for Change: Land Cover Updating in Isabela for a Sustainable Future held on 7 December 2020.
The local collaboration in the Isabela Land Cover Assessment (ILCA) project is impressive. It is essential, otherwise, it would have been purely academic. We can see that there are many people who want to use this data. This is what’s important, that people see a purpose in it.
Today, we need a purpose-based science that serves society. We have in this effort both the method and the training. It’s not contained and owned: it serves. It is very important that it gets out. And it has been said many times that this is just the beginning.
I think that what we are all edging at – all of the speakers in different ways – is the crux of what we are facing: how do we establish a balanced land use? How do we balance that with people, food, and biodiversity?
It’s not an economic equation. However, that’s what it is usually reduced to, and this is very sad, and often an illegal economic equation. This is what we are struggling with. We don’t have a value for forest and water, let alone biodiversity. We don’t actually value water; we have to pay companies for it. But we do not have a national value given to it. It’s free for exploitation, and this is part of the problem.
The data is there, it can be used in multiple ways, and because of the nature of the data and its future compilations, it can be integral to planning and implementation.
Our second speaker, Stefan Kienberger, reminds us of the work we’ve been doing, and the tremendous work he has done on risk, hazard, vulnerability, and exposure. We have gone through this in many sites in the Philippines, but we have to learn it in every region and every province. We cannot learn from another province; it has to be integral to the province.
Unfortunately, we need one disaster after another to integrate it across the country. We went through this in 1991 in Ormoc. We said then that this is the “new norm.” We did not need COVID to give us a new norm. We knew Ormoc was the new norm of flooding in the Philippines, and every disaster since then has confirmed it.
Yes, we can measure whether this is a hundred-year event or not, but if you build in the impacts of forest destruction, infrastructure, worsening of natural systems with urbanization, and loss of forest cover, that’s not a one-in-a-hundred flood as what was said. We haven’t gotten a hold of dam data as to the release of water. When it was released is crucial as we integrate it in the story.
There is much greater access in some areas to the information – this complicated information – but we need all of these to become operational. That’s what Stefan was saying. How do we become operational? That’s the challenge as all of us bring this data forward. It’s to make it operational so that it means something to people’s lives, not just to the national economy.
We are full of hotspots; whether it’s hotspots for disasters, or whether it’s hotspots for biodiversity. Merlijn van Weerd has given us a beautiful tour of biodiversity, because in the Philippines, we still pretty much think that the Philippine Eagle is it. It has not gotten into our life system.
Most of these for people are pretty pictures, but they are not our life. And that is what the Agta people show us and many others: it’s a life, and it is an integrated life. And we need most of all to learn from Indigenous Peoples. They are the most integrated, but we put an emphasis on economy over integration.
And of course, the tipping point of all these is that we don’t get it. We don’t get the losses, we are on the edge of it. This is a crisis now; it is not something to be solved in the next decade. We will not have it in a decade – the integrity of limestone forests, the integrity of these small biomes that give us so much.
So much of this challenge is now on the table of Atty. Eduardo Cabantac. He has a massive job ahead of him, and I am very happy to hear about the bill, although I’m not too sure if development authorities are quite the answer.
So, we look for a reformulation of the development authorities and we hope it’s for human development and environmental sustainability. The word ‘development’ has gotten a little overused these days, and we need to make it something that is truly positive for all life, for all beings. We are with the Isabela Province on this in however we can support to bring about the integrity of the province and the entire watershed.
We go from one end of the Philippines to the other, and it’s one of the most beautiful places. And it does not have a price. You can’t cut off the national park and say it’s separate. It should be integral to how we live, and we should naturally respect it.
And we should try not to get around the problems that are there. It’s very sad to see the extent of mining, and this is mining for export. It’s like in Bukidnon where I am – more pigs are fed than people with the amount of corn grown here. What is the economy for? It fuels the highways; it does not fuel the homes. We need this balance.
There is so much that can be said, and there’s so much that has been presented that is encouraging, but we need the integration. The challenge, the choice now, is to integrate. I ask us all, where possible, to seek out this integration and integrity: the integrity of the environment and the integrity of our society depends upon this.

Good evening, I one of your participants during “BENTELA DAW SAYODA” in bukidnon, 11 years ago.. I love to participate In your programs, looking forward to be with your growing program again.. I currently active in participating to several CSO programs that aims to protect vulnerable.. I love to be invited in one of your activities..
Special thanks to ma’am KANG ZONZA, one of your facilitator during the Bentela, I hope she still remember me.